NY Thruway (I-87) exit 19 - follow sign to Pine Hill off the traffic circle onto Route 28 West. Follow route 28 West for about 35 miles (approx 15 miles past Phoenicia and 2 miles past Pine Hill) - pass entrance to Belleayre Mtn on your left, down the hill, look for Fleischmanns sign on right, and turn there onto Main street. Follow road about 1/2 mile, past gas station on right, first left onto Wagner Ave. Follow Wagner Ave. 1/4 miles as it curves right up hill, past Pine Tree Lane (on left) - 538 Wagner Ave will be 3rd driveway on left. Park in front of Garage. If you get to the stop sign at Bridge St you have gone too far.
Alternate scenic route. Stay on route 28 past first Fleischmanns turnoff. Go one mile, and look for 2nd fleischmanns turnoff on right (Depot St). Go 0.2 mile and take first right onto Wagner Ave. Drive past all the lovely Victorian homes, old hotels, B&B's, tennis courts, soccer field and outdoor pool. After 0.5 mile you will come to stop sign at Bridge St (on left). Go thru intersection, up hill about 0.2 miles to 538 Wagner. If you get to Pine Tree Lane on right you have gone too far.
From west: Route 28 East from Margaretteville about 6 miles. Just after Wadler Bros. home center (on left), look for Fleischmanns turnoff on left and follow scenic route directions above.